BIG LIST OF WEBSITES

List of Top Websites Like Pnas.org

Top 250 Websites Like PNAS.ORG

Download the Top 250 Websites to PDF

Last updated on Jan 1 2020.
Here are the best websites we found: pnas.org • pnas.fr • circuitscape.org • circuitscape.org • nas-online.org • pnas.in • edeka-liebt-kochen.de • relationalmobility.org • ijirt.org

Press CTRL-D to bookmark this list - BigListofWebsites.com
Rank
Url
Preview
Tags
Score
PNAS
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Accueil Cabinet PNAS. Accueil Cabinet PNAS
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Circuitscape | Circuitscape is an award-winning connectivity analysis software package which borrows algorithms from electronic circuit theory to predict patterns of movement, gene flow, and genetic differentiation among plant and animal populations in heterogeneous landscapes. Circuitscape has rapidly become the most widely used connectivity analysis package in the world. It is used by numerous state, federal, and local agencies in the USA, and by government ministries and NGOs for conservation planning on six continents. It routinely appears in journals like PNAS, Nature Genetics, Ecology, Ecological Applications, Ecology Letters, Landscape Ecology, Evolution, Heredity, Bioscience, Molecular Ecology, Conservation Biology, and many others.. Circuitscape is an award-winning connectivity analysis software package which borrows algorithms from electronic circuit theory to predict patterns of movement, gene flow, and genetic differentiation among plant and animal populations in heterogeneous landscapes. Circuitscape has rapidly become the most widely used connectivity analysis package in the world. It is used by numerous state, federal, and local agencies in the USA, and by government ministries and NGOs for conservation planning on six continents. It routinely appears in journals like PNAS, Nature Genetics, Ecology, Ecological Applications, Ecology Letters, Landscape Ecology, Evolution, Heredity, Bioscience, Molecular Ecology, Conservation Biology, and many others.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Circuitscape | Circuitscape is an award-winning connectivity analysis software package which borrows algorithms from electronic circuit theory to predict patterns of movement, gene flow, and genetic differentiation among plant and animal populations in heterogeneous landscapes. Circuitscape has rapidly become the most widely used connectivity analysis package in the world. It is used by numerous state, federal, and local agencies in the USA, and by government ministries and NGOs for conservation planning on six continents. It routinely appears in journals like PNAS, Nature Genetics, Ecology, Ecological Applications, Ecology Letters, Landscape Ecology, Evolution, Heredity, Bioscience, Molecular Ecology, Conservation Biology, and many others.. Circuitscape is an award-winning connectivity analysis software package which borrows algorithms from electronic circuit theory to predict patterns of movement, gene flow, and genetic differentiation among plant and animal populations in heterogeneous landscapes. Circuitscape has rapidly become the most widely used connectivity analysis package in the world. It is used by numerous state, federal, and local agencies in the USA, and by government ministries and NGOs for conservation planning on six continents. It routinely appears in journals like PNAS, Nature Genetics, Ecology, Ecological Applications, Ecology Letters, Landscape Ecology, Evolution, Heredity, Bioscience, Molecular Ecology, Conservation Biology, and many others.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
www.pnas.org | 502: Bad gateway
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Archive of all online content | PNAS
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
WMF | Pnas and Pots. Diese Treueaktion ist beendet.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
The Relational Mobility Portal | Discover the socioecological variable RELATIONAL MOBILITY. The companion website for the PNAS relational mobility article titled
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
ISSN approved and Scopus Journal IJIRT.org Call For Paper June 2019 International Journal of Innovative Research in Technology. UGC approved journal,ugc approved journal,ugc and issn approved,ugc approved, ugc,UGC, UGC approved journal , ugc approved journal,issue,paper,research,journal,ijirt,international,volume,author,publication,SCOPUS approved journal, scopus, SCOPUS Indexed Journal, Scopus Journal, free publication, publish free, free of cost publication, free,internationaljouranl,journal,research,research paper,International Journal of Innovative Research in Technology,ISSN: 2349-6002,iisn,how publish paper,publish paper, good research journal,good journal,best research journal,top 10 research journal,research journal of biotechnology, research journal of agricultural sciences, research journal of recent sciences, research journal of chemical sciences, research journal of pharmacy and technology, research journal of microbiology, research journal of medicinal plant, research journal of information technology, research journal of environmental sciences, research journal of pharmacognosy and phytochemistry, research journal articles, research journal agricultural science, research journal articles pdf, research journal about culture, research journal article example, research journal about culture pdf, research journal app, research journal aion, research journal abstract, research journal about filipino culture, a research journal of south asian studies, a research journal allows you to, obesity a research journal, writing a research journal, an international research journal, example of a research journal, transportation research a journal, how to review a research journal, research journal biotechnology, research journal biological sciences, research journal biotechnology impact factor, research journal biology, research journal business, research journal business management, research journal botany, research journal brain, research journal biological pharmaceutical chemical sciences, research based journal articles, research journal cover letter, research journal citation, research journal chemical sciences, research journal club, research journal chemistry environment, research journal cell, research journal com, research journal chemistry, research journal commerce, research journal child development, transportation research c journal, research journal definition, research journal database, research journal dentistry, research journal dairy sciences, research journal design, research disclosure journal, research drops journal kurukshetra, research digest journal, research digest journal bilaspur, research dimensions journal, 4 d research journal, vitamin d research journal, transportation research d journal, research journal example, research journal engineering applied sciences, research journal environmental sciences, research journal engineering, research journal entry, research journal education, research journal environmental earth sciences, research journal environmental toxicology impact factor, research journal environmental toxicology, research journal english literature, e-research journal, e-commerce research journal, e-research a journal of undergraduate work, e-library research journal, e-international scientific research journal, elibrary science research journal, e-society journal research and applications, educational research e-journal, transportation research e journal, variorum multidisciplinary e research journal, research journal format, research journal for veterinary practitioners, research journal free, research journal finance and accounting, research journal fisheries hydrobiology, research journal for chemistry, research journal for nursing, research journal for psychology, research journal finance, research journal for recent sciences, research journal genetics, research journal guc, researchgate journal finder, researchgate journal, journal research gender studies, researchgate journal of biological chemistry, research global journal, fisheries research journal guide for authors, brain research journal guide for authors, research journal of geography, g i research journal, research journal hindi, research journal hindi literature, research journal health, research journal how to write, research journal history, research journal how to, research hunt journal, journal research health sciences, journal of healthcare research, journal research higher education, research journal in education, research journal impact factor, research journal in india, research journal in biotechnology, research journal in engineering and applied sciences, research journal in chemistry and environment, research journal in hindi, research journal in microbiology, research journal in pharmaceutical sciences, research journal in commerce and management, jnkvv research journal, j proteome research journal, research journal keeping, education research journal kenneth williams, legume research journal karnal, pollution research journal karad, research journal of krishna institute karad, agricultural research journal kenneth williams, christian research journal kindle, environmental engineering research journal korea, research in kinesiology journal, k-12 research journals, research journal list, research journal layout, research journal latur, research journal labome, research journal library, research journal literature review, research link journal, research link journal indore, journal research lepidoptera, journal research leadership education, research journal medicinal plant, research journal mechanical engineering, research journal meaning, research journal microbiology, research journal medical sciences, research journal management, research journal medicine medical sciences, research journal medical, research journal mathematics statistics, research journal methodology, applied h.r.m. research journal, research journal names, research journal nature, research journal nursing, research journal nanoscience nanotechnology, research journal notebook, research notes journal, journal research national bureau standards, research nursing journal articles, journal research national institute standards technology, journal research nursing health, research journal of applied sciences engineering and technology, research journal of chemistry and environment, review of research journal, example of research journal, quality of research journal indication, research journal pdf, research journal publish, research journal publications, research journal pharmaceutical biological chemical sciences, research journal paper, research journal philippines, research journal psychology, research journal publication format, research journal pharmacy technology, research journal parasitology, research journal qualitative, research journal quality, research journal quality indicators, research journal quadratic equation, research quarterly journal, journal research quarterly for exercise and sport, research question journal, journal research quarterly for exercise and support, studio research journal qca, reading research quarterly journal, research journal rewa, research journal ranking, research journal related to facilitating learning, research journal recent sciences, research journal review, research journal reading, journal research rural education, research journal of recent sciences impact factor, educational research review journal, water research resources journal, hvac r research journal, ashrae hvac r research journal, research journal social sciences panjab university, research journal sample, research journal sites, research journal search, research journal subscription, research journals, research journal search engine, research journal social sciences, research journal science, research journal seed science, research journal template, research journal template word, research journal topics, research journal textile apparel, research journal textile, research journal teaching english, research journal tourism, research trends journal, journal research technology management, journal research technology education, journal research us geological survey, journal research updates polymer science, scientific research journal uitm, educational research journal uk, nursing research journal uk, cancer research journal uk, seaweed research utilization journal, international food research journal upm, research journal of aleppo university, seaweed research utilization journal impact factor, university research journal, university research journal of dentistry, sindh university research journal, mehran university research journal of engineering & technology, anna university research journals, punjab university research journal, panjab university research journal, kurukshetra university research journal, gomal university research journal, sindh university research journal impact factor, research visual journal, research vistas journal, journal research veterinary science, research virology journal, research veterinary journal, research vs journal article, cancer research journal vitamin c, anticancer research journal vitamin d, research journal for veterinary practitioners impact factor, research journal wiki, research journal with impact factor, research journal website, research journal wow, research journal writing, research journal water pollution control federation, research journal wpcf, research journal writing format, research world journal, creativity research journal website, research journal of international studies xvii, research journal of international studies xix, research journal of international studies xvi, research journal of international studies xi, research journal of international studies xiv, research journal of international studies xxii, research journal of international studies xii, christian research journal yoga, youth research journal, yeast research journal, yoga research journal, yarmouk research journal, american educational research journal in educational researcher, research journal of zoology, zenith research journal, zoological research journal, zahedan research journal, research & reviews journal of zoological sciences, zoo research journal, zoonoses research journal, nursing research journal 1952, first nursing research journal 1952, applied nursing research journal 1988, international food research journal 1, international food research journal 16, international food research journal 18 4, tier 1 research journals, trends research journal 2012 pdf, trends research journal 2012, dance research journal 2012, cancer research journal 2013, accounting research journal 2010, anticancer research journal 2003, textile research journal 2012, cancer research journal 2012, textile research journal 2010, jnkvv research journal 2012, grassroots writing research journal 3.1, grassroots writing research journal 3.2, british educational research journal 36, 3d research journal, buy grassroots writing research journal 3.1, medical research journal sims 3, sims 3 medical research journals, research journal for english literature, research journal for middle-earth gastroenterologists, research journal for creative cities, research journal for students, research journal for computer science, research for journalists, research for journalism, getty research journal 5, top 10 research journals, top 10 cancer research journals, paper publication and presentation, paper publication in journals, paper publication sites for mechanical engineering, paper publication sites for computer engineering, paper publication for computer science, paper publication in ieee, paper publication in resume, paper publication sites for electronics, paper publications and presentations resume, paper publication sites for ece, paper publication sample, publication paper antitrust, difference between paper publication and patent, is conference paper a publication, asme paper publication, academic paper publication, publication and paper settings tab, acm paper publication, article paper publication, stora enso publication paper anjalankoski, writing a publication paper, citation of a paper publication, what is a paper publication, submitting a paper for publication, preparing a paper for publication, reviewing a paper for publication, how to make a paper publication, paper publication bristol, stora enso publication paper borlange, ibps previous paper bsc publication, best paper publication, paper publication certificate, paper publication cover letter, paper publication cost, paper publication on computer science, ieee paper publication charges, ieee paper publication cost, paper publication for change of name, paper publication in commerce, paper publication in chemistry, the paper conservator publication, paper publication dates, ieee paper publication date, paper bag princess publication date, paper publication for loss of documents, design paper publication, draft paper publication, publication paper demand, stora enso publication paper dsseldorf, publication paper definition, paper publication english literature, paper publication elsevier, paper publication electronics, paper publication in education, paper publication in mechanical engineering, paper publication in physical education, cse white paper publication ethics, engineering paper publication, epaper hindustan times publications 2011 index, paper publication format ieee, paper publication for civil engineering, paper publication format, paper publication fees, paper publication for name change, paper publication for phd, paper for publication, ijca paper publication fee, paper publication guidelines, publication paper grades, ieee paper publication guidelines, green paper publication, google paper publication, stora enso publication paper gmbh, stora enso publication paper gmbh & co. kg, stora enso publication paper gmbh hagen, research paper publication help, stora enso publication paper hagen, stora enso publication paper hyltebruk, paper publication in india, paper publication in management journals, paper publication in law, paper publication in springer, paper publication in national journal, paper publication in journals 2014, paper publication journals, research paper publication journals, paper publication international journals, free paper publication journals, writing paper publication journal, paper publication in journals 2012, journal paper publication process, stora enso publication paper kvarnsveden mill, stora enso publication paper karlsruhe, stora enso publication paper kabel mill, legal paper publication, law paper publication india, paper publication meaning, publication paper manufacturers, paper publication in management, paper publication in mathematics, white paper publication meaning, medical paper publication, maths paper publication, paper publication notice, national paper publication, newspaper publication, nature paper publication, reflection paper on publication of withdrawals, white paper on publication, online paper publication, publication of paper, publication of paper in journals how, paper towns date of publication, online paper publication free, format of paper publication, process of paper publication, sample of paper publication, types of paper publications, advantages of paper publication, importance of paper publication, paper publication process, paper publication procedure, research paper publication process, scientific paper publication process, technical paper publication process, ieee paper publication procedure, research paper publication ppt, science paper publication process, paper publication resume, research paper publication, research paper publication in india, research paper publication sites, research paper publication in journal, review paper publication, red pepper publication uganda, research paper publication website, paper publication sites for electrical, paper publication sites, paper publication sites for computer science, publication paper sca, publication paper sizes, paper publication tips, paper publication topics, paper publication topics in computer science, paper publication topics in mechanical engineering, paper publication time, publication paper template, paper towns publication information, ieee paper publication template, technical paper publication, paper publication uk, paper publication website, paper publication wiki, white paper publication, working paper publication, wall paper publication, stora enso publication paper werk maxau, paper publication 2015, paper publication 2014, paper publication 2013, call for paper publication 2013, call for paper publication 2014, international research journal of pharmacy, international research journal of biological sciences, international research journal of environmental sciences, international research journal of social sciences, international research journal of engineering and technology, international research journal of finance and economics, international research journal of pharmacy impact factor, international research journal of medical sciences, international research journal of library and information science, international research journal of engineering and technology (ijret), international research journal applied and basic sciences, international research journal agricultural science, international research journal agricultural science impact factor, international journal research and development, international journal research and reviews in applied sciences, international journal research and review, international journal research and method in education, international research journal of applied finance, international food research journal abbreviation, international research journal of arts and social sciences, an international research journal of chemical sciences, an international research journal, an international multidisciplinary research journal, early years an international research journal, international research journal biotechnology, international research journal banks and bank systems, international research journal biotechnology impact factor, international research journal basic applied sciences, international journal research biological sciences, international research journal of biochemistry and bioinformatics, international research journal of basic and clinical studies, international research journal of business studies, international research journal of bacteriology, international research journal of basic and clinical studies impact factor, international research journal computer science, international research journal consortium, international journal research chemistry environment, international journal research commerce management, international journal research choral singing, international research journal of computer science and information systems, international research journal of commerce business and social sciences, international research journal of chemistry, international research journal of computer science engineering and applications, international research journal of chemical sciences, international journal research development, international dental research journal, international research journal of musicology and drama, international dairy research journal, international research journal of global business development, international journal dipterological research, early years international journal research development, international design research journal, international journal dream research, darshan international research journal of philosophy and yoga, international research journal education, international research journal english literature, international research journal economics, international research journal economics finance, international research journal of engineering science technology and innovation, international research journal of environmental sciences impact factor, international research journal of engineering and technologies, international research journal of engineering science technology and innovation impact factor, international research journal of engineering sciences, e-international scientific research journal, e-international scientific research journal abbreviation, international research e-journals, e international journal educational research, international research journal for inventions in pharmaceutical sciences, international research journal for quality in education, international research journal finance economics, international research journal for quality in higher education, international research journal finance economics issues irjfe, international research journal for medical students, international research journal for social science and corporate excellence, international research journal finance, international research food journal, international journal research finance marketing, international research journal geology mining, international research journal of geology and mining impact factor, international research journal of sports glimpses, international food research journal author guidelines, international global research journal, international journal geophysical research, genetics research international journal, international & indexed journal golden research thoughts, genetics research international journal impact factor, international research journal of humanities, international research journal of humanities and environmental issues, international research journal of humanities engineering & pharmaceutical sciences, international research journal in hindi, international research journal of horticulture, international research journal of humanities impact factor, international research journal of human resource management pdf, international research journal of health and food sciences, international research journal of hindi literature, international research journal of horticulture impact factor, international research journal in engineering science and technology, international research journal impact factor, international research journal in finance and economics, international research journal in computer science, international research journal in education, international research journal in pharmacy, international research journal in applied finance, international journal research in marketing, international journal research in commerce and management, international journal research in pharmaceutical sciences, i xplore international research journal consortium, international research journal of journalism and mass communication, international journal of environmental research journal, international journal of production research journal, international journal of energy research journal, international journal of tourism research journal, international journal of materials research journal, international journal of educational research journal, international journal of scientific research journal, international journal of agricultural research journal, international journal of chemtech research journal, international journal kaatsu training research, international journal of kaatsu research, international research journal language society and culture, international research journal lab to land, international research journal library information science, international research journal of library information and archival studies, international research journal of law, international research journal of languages, international research journal of library information and archival, international research journal of life sciences, international research journal of literature, international research journal microbiology, international research journal microbiology impact factor, international research journal management business studies, international journal research marketing, international journal research methodology, international journal research method education, international research journal of medicine and medical sciences, international research journal of medicine and medical sciences impact factor, international food research journal malaysia, international research journal of natural sciences, international food research journal naas rating, international scholarly research network journal, international rice research notes journal, international scholarly research notices journal, international scholarly research network journal impact factor, international mathematics research notices journal, international nursing research journal, international journal nano research, neurology research international journal, international of food research journal, impact factor of international research journals, international research journal pharmacy, international research journal plant science, international research journal plant science impact factor, international research journal problems and perspectives in management, international research journal pharmacy pharmacology impact factor, international research journal pharmacy pharmacology, international journal research paper, international journal research pharmaceutical sciences, international journal research publications, international journal research paper submission cfp, international journal qualitative research, international journal quality research, quest international research journal, international journal qualitative research education, international journal of quantitative research in education, boreas international journal quaternary research, international journal of qualitative research in services, international journal on quranic research, international journal for quality research impact factor, international research review journal, international journal research reviews applied sciences impact factor, international journal research reviews applied sciences, international refereed research journal, international journal rehabilitation research, international journal robotics research, international journal radiation research, international journal robotics research impact factor, international journal of production research journal ranking, international research journal of finance and economics ranking, international research journal shodh samiksha aur mulyankan, international journal research studies in psychology, international research journal of social sciences and humanities, international research journal of social sciences impact factor, international research journal of science arts and commerce, international research journal of science and engineering, international research journal of social science and management, international food research journal scopus, international journal research technology, international journal research teacher education, international research journal of information technology, international journal tourism research, an international research journal in the field of chemical sciences, the international research journal of social science and management, international food research journal upm, international food research journal upm impact factor, international journal urban research, international undergraduate research journal, upstream international research journal, international journal urban regional research, international journal of veterinary research university of tehran, international journal of research in urology, international journal of research in urology impact factor, international journal of nano research usa, international research journal of virology, international turfgrass society research journal volume 11, international turfgrass society research journal volume 9, international journal veterinary research, international journal volleyball research, vinayaka international research journal of humanities and social sciences, vinayaka international research journal of science and technology, international journal vitamin research, international journal vitamin nutrition research, international journal applied research veterinary medicine, international food research journal website, international journal wine research, international research journal of mobile and wireless communications, international water research journal, www.international research journal.org, international journal wine business research, international weekly medical research journal, international journal chemistry research (www.ijcr.info), international journal energy research wiley, international journal web services research, research journal of international studies xvii, research journal of international studies xix, research journal of international studies xvi, research journal of international studies xi, research journal of international studies xiv, research journal of international studies xxii, research journal of international studies xii, early years international research journal, international journal of yoga research, early years an international research journal impact factor, international journal zoological research, zenith international research journal, international journal zoological research impact factor, international journal of zoology research, international journal of zoological research abbreviation, international journal of zoology research impact factor, international journal of materials research zeitschrift fr metallkunde, international journal of materials research zeitschrift fuer metallkunde, international food research journal 1, international food research journal 16, international food research journal 18 4, international research journal of finance and economics issue 116, 1. international journal of academic research, international multidisciplinary research journal 2011, international multidisciplinary research journal 2012, international food research journal 2012, international food research journal 2013, international clil research journal 2009, international research journal of pharmacy 2012, international refereed research journal june 2011, international business and economics research journal 2012, international food research journal impact factor 2012, international food research journal impact factor 2011, international food research journal 2, crop research - an international journal 3.4, international journal of educational research 33, international journal of educational research 37, international journal of educational research 39, international journal of educational research 31, international research journal for finance and economics, international research journal for inventions in pharmaceutical sciences impact factor, international scholarly research journal for interdisciplinary studies, international journal of production research 5 year impact factor, international journal of educational research 58, top research journals, top research journals in computer science, top research journals in management, top research journals in finance, top research journals in education, top operations research journals, top cancer research journals, top accounting research journals, top medical research journals, top nursing research journals, top research journal, top operations research journal, top cancer research journal, top qualitative research journal, top journal in operations research, top journal in cancer research, top journal operations research, top health services research journals, top 10 research journals, top 10 cancer research journals, highly impact factor journals, high impact factor journals computer science, high impact factor of journals, high impact journals, high impact journals in medicine, high impact journals 2014, high impact journals in physics, high impact journals in engineering, high impact journals in psychology, high impact journals in neuroscience, high impact journals in biology, high impact journals chemistry, high impact journals 2015, high impact journal list, high impact journals medical, high impact nursing journals, high impact factor nursing journals, high impact factor nanotechnology journals, high impact urology journals, high impact veterinary journals, high impact factor veterinary journals, high impact factor vascular journals, high impact journals 2012, high impact factor journals 2013, high impact factor journals 2012, top 10 high impact journals, impact factor of journals, impact factor of journals 2015, impact factor of nature, impact factor 2015, impact factor search, impact factor of plos one, impact factor of journals 2014, impact factor of ieee, impact factor of rsc advances, impact factor of ijca, impact factor of journals, impact factor of journals 2015, impact factor of nature, impact factor 2015, impact factor search, impact factor of plos one, impact factor of journals 2014, impact factor of ieee, impact factor meaning, impact factor of rsc advances, impact factor applied physics letters, impact factor acs nano, impact factor and h index, impact factor as per google search, impact factor applied surface science, impact factor aip advances, impact factor agency, impact factor advanced materials, impact factor analytical chemistry, impact factor applied physics a, an impact factor, a good impact factor, a&a impact factor 2012, nanotechnology a impact factor, physical review a impact factor, physics letters a impact factor, journal chromatography a impact factor, materials chemistry a impact factor, acta physica polonica a impact factor, j phys chem a impact factor, impact factor bioresource technology, impact factor bba, impact factor bulletin of materials science, impact factor biosensors and bioelectronics, impact factor biochemistry, impact factor bmc research notes, impact factor by thomson reuters, impact factor biomaterials, impact factor bioorganic and medicinal chemistry, impact factor bba molecular cell research, physica b impact factor, josa b impact factor, proceedings b impact factor, jvst b impact factor, pier b impact factor, b-ent impact factor, tellus b impact factor, nim b impact factor, proc b impact factor, jpc b impact factor, impact factor calculation, impact factor current science, impact factor cell, impact factor carbon, impact factor chemical engineering journal, impact factor checker, impact factor chemistry journals, impact factor ceramics international, impact factor computer science journals, impact factor chem comm, physica c impact factor, jpc c impact factor, pier c impact factor, pss c impact factor, acta c impact factor, jmc c impact factor, et c impact factor, epjc impact factor, jzus-c impact factor, pier c impact factor 2012, impact factor definition, impact factor dalton transactions, impact factor dental journals, impact factor desalination, impact factor der pharma chemica, impact factor dermatology journals, impact factor der pharmacia lettre, impact factor diabetes, impact factor development, impact factor developmental cell, acta d impact factor, physica d impact factor, acta d impact factor 2012, g&d impact factor, epjd impact factor, physics d impact factor, g&d impact factor 2011, etr d impact factor, physical review d impact factor, d lib magazine impact factor, impact factor elsevier, impact factor energy, impact factor electrochimica acta, impact factor elife, impact factor environmental science and technology, impact factor epw, impact factor environmental monitoring and assessment, impact factor european journal of medicinal chemistry, impact factor elsevier 2015, impact factor elsevier journals, e-impact factor, physica e impact factor, e polymers impact factor, acta e impact factor, acta e impact factor 2012, elife impact factor, e polymers impact factor 2012, e spen impact factor, e-polymers impact factor 2010, e blood impact factor, impact factor for journals, impact factor for ijaer, impact factor formula, impact factor for ieee, impact factor finder, impact factor for ijert, impact factor for nature, impact factor for springer, impact factor for plos one, impact factor food chemistry, acta f impact factor, acta f impact factor 2012, transportation research f impact factor, physical review f impact factor, acta crystallogr sect f impact factor, impact factor gene, impact factor green chemistry, impact factor genomics, impact factor genetics, impact factor geophysical research letters, impact factor google scholar, impact factor genome announcements, impact factor good journal, impact factor gastroenterology, impact factor genome research, g cubed impact factor, g&d impact factor, g&d impact factor 2011, j phys g impact factor, imeche part g impact factor, journal of physics g impact factor 2010, g chir impact factor, g ital cardiol impact factor, g ital nefrol impact factor, g ital dermatol venereol impact factor, impact factor highest, impact factor hindawi journals, impact factor how to calculate, impact factor high or low good, impact factor human molecular genetics, impact factor human brain mapping, impact factor hypertension, impact factor hepatology, impact factor health affairs, impact factor hematology, h impact factor calculator, h index impact factor conversion, h index versus impact factor, h-index (author impact factor), imeche part h impact factor, h index google scholar impact factor, acta microbiol imm h impact factor, h-index e impact factor, european physical journal h impact factor, indice h-impact factor, impact factor ieee, impact factor ijca, impact factor in research, impact factor ijaer, impact factor ijert, impact factor in bridge design, impact factor indian journal of physics, impact factor in research methodology, impact factor indian journals, impact factor inorganic chemistry, i i impact factor, impact factor journal, impact factor journals 2015, impact factor journal of applied physics, impact factor journal list 2015, impact factor jacs, impact factor journal of biological chemistry, impact factor jcc, impact factor journal of applied polymer science, impact factor journal of environmental chemical engineering, impact factor journal of magnetism and magnetic materials, embo j impact factor, faseb j impact factor, j neurosci impact factor, j immunol impact factor, j physiol impact factor, biochem j impact factor, embo j impact factor 2012, j neurophysiol impact factor, j neurochem impact factor, biophys j impact factor, impact factor ksce journal of civil engineering, impact factor key engineering materials, impact factor kidney international, impact factor kidney journals, impact factor kssta, impact factor knee, impact factor knowledge, impact factor korean journal of urology, impact factor kew bulletin, impact factor knowledge and information systems, k-theory impact factor, impact factor list 2015, impact factor list, impact factor list 2014, impact factor list 2015 pdf, impact factor list 2014 xls, impact factor langmuir, impact factor lung india, impact factor list 2015 xls, impact factor list 2014 pdf, impact factor law journals, l''impact factor, l o impact factor, pier l impact factor, l&o methods impact factor, l''enseignement mathematique impact factor, physical review l impact factor, l encphale impact factor, connaitre l''impact factor d''une revue, calculer l''impact factor, l''anthropologie impact factor, impact factor meaning, impact factor medical journals, impact factor materials letters, impact factor management journals, impact factor materials research bulletin, impact factor microbiology, impact factor medicinal chemistry research, impact factor more than 5, impact factor molecular simulation, impact factor materials science in semiconductor processing, pier m impact factor, m hikari impact factor, pier m impact factor 2013, pier m impact factor 2012, pier m impact factor 2011, msom impact factor, i&m impact factor, mbio impact factor, [email protected]@gement impact factor, m/c journal impact factor, impact factor nature, impact factor nature communications, impact factor nejm, impact factor nanoscale, impact factor nature scientific reports, impact factor new journal of chemistry, impact factor nano letters, impact factor neuroscience, impact factor nano energy, impact factor new journal of physics, n biotechnol impact factor, n j phys impact factor, n engl j med impact factor, n z med j impact factor, [email protected]@gement impact factor, impact factor n/a, n engl j med impact factor 2009, hand (n y) impact factor, cesk slov neurol n impact factor, n england j med impact factor, impact factor of journals, impact factor of journals 2015, impact factor of nature, impact factor of plos one, impact factor of journals 2014, impact factor of ieee, impact factor of rsc advances, impact factor of ijca, impact factor of scientific reports, impact factor of science, l o impact factor, triple o impact factor, l&o methods impact factor, triple o journal impact factor, impact factor o, l o journal impact factor, o que impact factor, impact factor plos one, impact factor pnas, impact factor pdf, impact factor ppt, impact factor physical review e, impact factor physical review letters, impact factor physica b, impact factor physical review b, impact factor physics letters b, impact factor physical review a, ap&p impact factor, p t impact factor, p t journal impact factor, j a p impact factor, p r b impact factor, physiol mol plant p impact factor, clin exp pharmacology p impact factor, transplant p impact factor, impact factor quaternary international, impact factor query, impact factor qualitative health research, impact factor quality of life research, impact factor quartile, impact factor quaternary science reviews, impact factor qualitative research journal, impact factor quality engineering, impact factor quarterly journal of experimental psychology, impact factor quarterly review of economics and finance, psychiatr q impact factor, q science impact factor, vet q impact factor, milbank q impact factor, ultrasound q impact factor, healthc q impact factor, misq impact factor, q j med impact factor, q rev biophys impact factor, stronglight impact q factor, impact factor rsc advances, impact factor range, impact factor ranking, impact factor researchgate, impact factor royal society of chemistry, impact factor range for journals, impact factor release date 2015, impact factor redox biology, impact factor ranking 2014, impact factor radiology, pm r impact factor, r journal impact factor, a&r impact factor, hvac&r impact factor, r news impact factor, embo r impact factor, r&d management impact factor, alcatel telecommun r impact factor, r&d magazine impact factor, pm&r journal impact factor, impact factor search, impact factor scientific reports, impact factor science, impact factor should be high or low, impact factor scale, impact factor sci, impact factor springer, impact factor scopus, impact factor small, impact factor springerplus, dcds s impact factor, bmj q s impact factor, iupac journals) impact factor, pharmacoepidem dr s impact factor, s afr med j impact factor, s afr j sci impact factor, s afr j bot impact factor, s. afr. j. chem. impact factor, j chem res s impact factor, water s a impact factor, impact factor thomson reuters, impact factor thomson reuters 2015, impact factor tetrahedron, impact factor thin solid films, impact factor tetrahedron letters, impact factor tropical gastroenterology, impact factor talanta, impact factor the plant genome, impact factor types, impact factor taylor and francis, es&t impact factor, ap&t impact factor, t-ase impact factor, jmr&t impact factor, p t impact factor, t-ro impact factor, es&t impact factor 2010, t-mtt impact factor, physica scripta t impact factor, u of t impact factor, impact factor uif, impact factor urology, impact factor urban studies, impact factor ultramicroscopy, impact factor ultrasonics sonochemistry, impact factor urban ecosystems, impact factor urban geography, impact factor ultrasound in obstetrics and gynecology, impact factor ultrasonics, impact factor urologia internationalis, u of t impact factor, chem. res. chinese u. impact factor, kemija u industriji impact factor, u of t library impact factor, impact factor vaccine, impact factor vikalpa, impact factor vs h index, impact factor virology, impact factor veterinary journals, impact factor value, impact factor viruses, impact factor vs sjr, impact factor virology journal, impact factor vision research, rozhledy v chirurgii impact factor, impact factor wiki, impact factor world neurosurgery, impact factor wise list of journals, impact factor weebly, impact factor water research, impact factor web of science, impact factor what is good, impact factor water resources research, impact factor world development, impact factor website, polimery w medycynie impact factor, impact factor w polsce, impact factor w 2012, impact factor xls, impact factor xls 2013, impact factor xls 2011, impact factor xls 2010, impact factor xenobiotica, impact factor xenotransplantation, impact factor x-ray spectrometry, journal impact factor xls 2012, impact factor ieee xplore, journal impact factor xls 2011, x factor impact on the music industry, prx impact factor, method x impact factor, phys rev x impact factor, x ray spectrometry impact factor, double impact x factor, x-ray spectrom impact factor, physical review x impact factor 2013, bio x biol impact factor, x ray structure analysis impact factor, impact factor yale journal of biology and medicine, impact factor yeast, impact factor years, impact factor youtube, impact factor yonsei med j, impact factor young, impact factor young consumers, impact factor fems yeast research, impact factor five year, impact factor per year, hand (n y) impact factor, grasas y aceites impact factor, computacin y sistemas impact factor, ceramica y vidrio impact factor, grasas y aceites impact factor 2012, grasas y aceites impact factor 2013, grasas y aceites impact factor 2009, cirugia y cirujanos impact factor, endocrinologia y nutricion impact factor, madera y bosques impact factor, impact factor zootaxa, impact factor zaac, impact factor zoology, impact factor zookeys, impact factor zygote, impact factor zebrafish, impact factor zoology journals, impact factor zoologica scripta, impact factor zamm, impact factor zoomorphology, z naturforsch impact factor, z kristallogr impact factor, math z impact factor, z naturforschung impact factor, z. metallkd impact factor, z naturforsch impact factor 2012, z. kristallographie impact factor, z krist impact factor, z naturforsch impact factor 2010, z gastroenterology impact factor, impact factor 0.5, impact factor 0.2, impact factor 0.1, impact factor 0.8, impact factor 0.7, impact factor 0.9, impact factor 0.3, impact factor 0.6, impact factor 0.4, impact factor 0.47, impact factor 0, impact factor 10, impact factor 1 journals, impact factor 1.5, impact factor 100, impact factor 1.7, impact factor 1.5 good, impact factor 1996, impact factor 1995 pdf, impact factor 10 or above, impact factor 1.8, 1 impact factor journal, plos1 impact factor, tcas 1 impact factor, plos1 impact factor 2011, plos1 impact factor 2012, tier 1 impact factor, 1 year impact factor, perkin transactions 1 impact factor, perkin trans 1 impact factor, tier 1 journal impact factor, impact factor 2015, impact factor 2014, impact factor 2014 pdf, impact factor 2015 list, impact factor 2014 xls, impact factor 2015 pdf, impact factor 2013, impact factor 2015 xls, impact factor 2015 release date, impact factor 2013 pdf, tcas 2 impact factor, 2 year impact factor, pharmacologyonline 2 impact factor, 2 internal factors impact employment relationship, aip advances 2 impact factor, perkin transactions 2 impact factor, perkin trans 2 impact factor, scientific reports 2 impact factor, journals with 2 impact factor, impact factor 2, impact factor 3.5, impact factor 3 biotech, impact factor 3 journals, impact factor 3.2, impact factor 30, impact factor 3.1 (uif), impact factor 3.7, impact factor 3.1, impact factor 3013, impact factor 3d research, 3 biotech impact factor, paleo 3 impact factor, pharmacologyonline 3 impact factor, 3 biotech impact factor 2014, scientific reports 3 impact factor, journals with 3 impact factor, what 3 factors impact population, education 3 13 impact factor, impact factor 3 5, impact factor 4.5, impact factor 4 journals, impact factor 4 good, impact factor 40, impact factor 4or, impact factor 4.2, impact factor 1 4, naas impact factor 4.7, plos one impact factor 4.092, impact factor value icv 4.50, impact factor 5 journals, impact factor 5 year, impact factor 50, impact factor 5.5, jbr impact factor 5, journal impact factor 5 year, impact factor above 5, oncogene impact factor 5 year, impact factor 2 5, pnas impact factor 5 year, 5 impact factors golf, 5 impact factors golf pga, 5 year impact factor, 5 year impact factor list, 5 year impact factor isi, 5 year impact factor nature, 5 year impact factor 2012, 5-year impact factor plos one, 5 year impact factor calculation, 5 year impact factor pnas, impact factor 6 journal, impact factor 60, impact factor 6, plos one 6 impact factor, impact factor 6, impact factor 6 journal, nanoscale impact factor 7, journal impact factor 7, nature communications impact factor 7.396, impact factor 1 7, plos one 7 impact factor, impact factor 7, impact factor 8.459, impact factor 8nv, neurology impact factor 8.17, plos one 8 impact factor, impact factor 8, journal of hepatology impact factor 9.858, journal with impact factor 9, impact factor 9, impact factor 100, impact factor 10 or above, impact factor top 100, impact factor over 10, impact factor above 100, impact factor greater than 10, impact factor 2012 top 10, impact factor 2013 top 10, journals impact factor above 10, impact factor , top 10 impact factor journals, top 10 impact factor journals 2011, top 10 impact factor medical journals, top 10 impact factor for open access journals, top 10 impact factor scientific journals, impact factor 10 journals, issn number for journals, issn number for journals in india, issn number for online journals, issn number for journal, issn number for a journal, what is an issn number for journals, issn number in journal, issn number for online journal, issn number of journals in india, what is issn number for journal
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
BEACON | An NSF Center for the Study of Evolution in Action. By: Dr. Wenying Shou - Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center Sometimes in science, a seemingly straightforward journey can take an enormous amount of time. Our paper in PLoS Biology (Hart et al., 2019) was one such journey. The question seemed easy enough: for a highly simplified microbial community — a community of two yeast strains engineered to help each other or "cooperate", could we predict how fast the community might grow? If you think that this question is esoteric, it is not. Cooperation is surprisingly common in biology: pathogenic bacteria cooperate with each other to launch infections; microbes in sewage treatment sludge cooperate to break down wastes. The faster a community can grow, the more likely it will survive perturbations or advance to new territories. Ultimately, a quantitative understanding of microbial communities will empower us to control and use communities as, for example, probiotics. One remarkable aspect of this work — the very long and turbulent gestation — is invisible from the data themselves. When responding to journal reviewers' critiques, I had the urge to write down this untold story of scientific discovery. A humble dream The project started when I was a postdoc about 17 years ago. To tie biology with mathematics, I joined a physicist's lab at the Rockefeller University in New York City. I wanted to see how interacting "parts" of a biological system might generate quantitative properties of the system as a "whole". All biological systems consist of parts. For example, an ecological community consists of interacting species, and the human body consists of different cell types. A quantitative understanding of how a biological system works can be very powerful. For example, it could help us predict what would happen if we were to perturb a part. A mathematical model consists of one or more equations. An equation describes how different quantities are linked to each other. For example, how fast population size changes equals how fast new members are added through birth, minus how fast the existing members die. The growth and death rates are examples of model parameters. Back then, people had been modeling biological systems such as ecological communities, gene regulatory networks, and the cell division cycle. Some models matched data beautifully. However, the renowned mathematician and computer scientist John von Neumann once stated "with four parameters I can fit an elephant, and with five I can make him wiggle his trunk." In other words, given enough "free parameters" — parameters one could freely choose rather than being constrained by reality from experimental measurements, a model can be made to fit any data. Although a fitting model can explain data, it does not mean that the model is correct or can predict new data. To avoid the "free parameter" problem, I decided to start with a very simple system. In such a system, I should know exactly how parts interact with each other. I could then write down the equations, know which parameters need to be measured, and measure all parameters. After much deliberation, I decided to engineer a highly simplified cooperative yeast community consisting of two strains, each supplying the other with an essential metabolite. My colleagues and I thought of a lovely name for it: CoSMO — Cooperation that is Synthetic and Mutually Obligatory. Unlike real-life communities where scientists often have trouble counting the number of species, CoSMO has two and only two strains. Unlike real-life communities where species influence each other by releasing many uncharacterized chemicals, in CoSMO each strain releases only one metabolite which is required and consumed by the partner. Moreover in CoSMO, the two strains coexist due to their inter-dependence, and thus I do not need to worry about losing any one of them. Now that I know how the two strains interact with each other, it should in principle be easy to predict community properties, such as how fast the community grows — or community growth rate. Community growth rate primarily depends on two traits of each strain: the metabolite release rate and the amount of metabolite consumed per birth. Thus, modeling community growth rate boils down to measuring four parameters. This is by no means ambitious! Mission aborted I measured all four parameters. I measured the metabolite release and consumption traits of each strain in the absence of its partner. I got rid of the partner so that the released metabolites would accumulate in the test tube for me to measure, instead of being immediately consumed by the partner. However, since the partner was not present, the measurement environment (called the "batch culture" environment) differed from the community environment. For example, to measure metabolite consumption in batch cultures, I would add a high dose of metabolite at the beginning of an experiment. In contrast, in communities, the consumed metabolite is constantly supplied by the partner at a low level. Measuring strain traits in a community-like environment would require a special experimental setup. So, I had to hope that the batch culture environment could approximate the community environment. After measuring the four parameters, I predicted community growth rate. However, my prediction was way off from the experimental results. I was disappointed. In theory, a mathematical model is useful when it fails, because failure suggests that we are still missing important pieces. In reality, I was far from being thrilled by the failure, because too many pieces could be missing, even in a system as simple as CoSMO. For example, the batch culture environment might not approximate the community environment; cells could be evolving… The problem immediately becomes monstrously messy and un-elegant — a devil. Eventually, I aborted the mission. I was forced to ask whether I could explain some other community property — the minimal total cell density required for the community to start to grow. That calculation required measuring more parameters — such as cell growth rates at various metabolite concentrations. I did not have the experimental setup for such measurements, so I gave in to free parameters. I did what was, and is still, commonly done: looking for literature values. The literature values varied over an order of magnitude, so I naturally chose the value that could explain my data. I felt guilty, but comforted myself by noting that at least, the free parameter I chose was not outrageous, and that at least, the fraction of free parameters in my model was far lower than most other models. This reasoning did not exonerate me, but helped to bring a closure to my postdoc project (Shou et al., 2007). Haunted by the devil When I started my lab at the Hutch, I promptly locked up the devil in a closet. I felt caught: on the one hand, grant reviewers kept punishing me because "CoSMO is too simple", yet on the other hand, I could not even understand a very basic property of the community. My modeling failure was indeed humiliating. There was no way I could rephrase the question in an exciting fashion to attract any one, possibly even including myself. My group started working on other more sexy problems, such as how the two cooperating strains might fend off cheaters who consume but do not contribute metabolites (Momeni et al., 2013b; Waite and Shou, 2012). Despite group members' successes, the devil kept haunting me. Babak Momeni, then a postdoctoral fellow in my lab, examined spatial patterning in CoSMO when CoSMO grew on an agarose pad. When we compared patterns predicted by our model versus patterns observed in experiments, they looked similar in a qualitative sense. However, the timing looked very different. This is not surprising given that we do not understand how fast the community grows. Fortunately, dynamics was not the focus of that paper, so we erased all time stamps from our simulations (Momeni et al., 2013a). Devil breaking loose Eventually, the devil of my past failure would not allow me to ignore it any further. Chi-Chun Chen and Jose Pineda, two talented group members, were quantifying metabolite release rates of evolved cells. They wanted to see whether cells could evolve to be more "generous" by releasing more. However, Chi-Chun and Jose were getting highly variable results despite their superb experimental skills. It seemed that we got stuck when the question turned quantitative. We suspected that the variable measurement results could be due to cell traits being highly sensitive to the measurement environment. To enable measurements in a community-like environment, David Skelding — a physicist in the lab — started to build devices called "chemostats". In chemostats, nutrients were supplied at a small dose (in small drops) but frequently (every tens of seconds), mimicking partner strain's slow but constant metabolite release rate. It took David a good year or more to ensure that chemostats worked reliably and precisely (Skelding et al., 2018). Taming the devil When Sam Hart joined my lab as a research technician, he inherited the problems I, Chi-Chun, and Jose had left behind. Initially, Sam continued to quantify strain traits in batch cultures, because after all, chemostat measurements are much harder and are limited by the number of chambers. However, at some point, we realized that without getting our fundamentals on a solid footing, we would be chasing after our tails: If we do not understand the two ancestral strains (i.e. why ancestral strains' traits cannot explain ancestral community's growth rate), there is no point trying to understand evolved strains. By that time, Sam had already invested a year or two. But Sam was unflustered because he understood the importance of asking the right, albeit inconvenient, question. Sam re-measured ancestral strains' metabolite release and consumption traits in David's chemostats. By controlling how slowly metabolites were supplied, Sam could force cells to grow at various slow rates observed in CoSMO. However, chemostats introduced their own devil: because of metabolite limitation, cells from both strains quickly evolved away from their original states while adapting to metabolite limitation. Sam then figured out ways to deal with this new problem. Eventually, Sam discovered that indeed, measurements of metabolite release and consumption traits could differ significantly in chemostats versus in batch cultures. Hanbing Mi, an undergraduate visiting student from China, figured out how to properly measure community growth rate when cells could evolve quickly. Once we took all these into consideration, we solved the puzzle (Hart et al., 2019). But only partially: we still do not understand CoSMO's initial phase of slower growth. Using the same quantification methodology that we have found to be trustworthy, Sam figured out what it means to be "generous" (Hart & Pineda et al., 2019), and which mutants evolved to be more generous (manuscript in preparation). Sam is now a graduate student at the University of Washington. Summary It takes a lot to do careful science. For science to advance, it must stand on a solid foundation. By demonstrating how to properly model a very simple living system, we have helped setting the standard for future modeling of more complex systems such as probiotic communities or infectious diseases. Acknowledgements I am very grateful to my lab members, particularly Sam Hart, Hanbing Mi, Jose Pineda, Chi-Chun Chen, and David Skelding, for doing high-quality work. Hart & Pineda, Chen, Chichun, Green, Robin, Shou W. 2019. Disentangling strictly self-serving mutations from win-win mutations in a mutualistic microbial community. eLife Accepted. Hart SFM, Mi H, Green R, Xie L, Pineda JMB, Momeni B, Shou W. 2019. Uncovering and resolving challenges of quantitative modeling in a simplified community of interacting cells. PLOS Biol 17:e3000135. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3000135 Momeni B, Brileya KA, Fields MW, Shou W. 2013a. Strong inter-population cooperation leads to partner intermixing in microbial communities. eLife 2:e00230. doi:10.7554/eLife.00230 Momeni B, Waite AJ, Shou W. 2013b. Spatial self-organization favors heterotypic cooperation over cheating. eLife 2:e00960. doi:10.7554/eLife.00960 Shou W, Ram S, Vilar JM. 2007. Synthetic cooperation in engineered yeast populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104:1877–1882. doi:10.1073/pnas.0610575104 Skelding D, Hart SF, Vidyasagar T, Pozhitkov AE, Shou W. 2018. Developing a low-cost milliliter-scale chemostat array for precise control of cellular growth. Quant Biol 6:129–141. Waite AJ, Shou W. 2012. Adaptation to a new environment allows cooperators to purge cheaters stochastically. Proc Natl Acad Sci 109:19079–19086. doi:10.1073/pnas.1210190109
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
BEACON | An NSF Center for the Study of Evolution in Action. By: Dr. Wenying Shou - Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center Sometimes in science, a seemingly straightforward journey can take an enormous amount of time. Our paper in PLoS Biology (Hart et al., 2019) was one such journey. The question seemed easy enough: for a highly simplified microbial community — a community of two yeast strains engineered to help each other or "cooperate", could we predict how fast the community might grow? If you think that this question is esoteric, it is not. Cooperation is surprisingly common in biology: pathogenic bacteria cooperate with each other to launch infections; microbes in sewage treatment sludge cooperate to break down wastes. The faster a community can grow, the more likely it will survive perturbations or advance to new territories. Ultimately, a quantitative understanding of microbial communities will empower us to control and use communities as, for example, probiotics. One remarkable aspect of this work — the very long and turbulent gestation — is invisible from the data themselves. When responding to journal reviewers' critiques, I had the urge to write down this untold story of scientific discovery. A humble dream The project started when I was a postdoc about 17 years ago. To tie biology with mathematics, I joined a physicist's lab at the Rockefeller University in New York City. I wanted to see how interacting "parts" of a biological system might generate quantitative properties of the system as a "whole". All biological systems consist of parts. For example, an ecological community consists of interacting species, and the human body consists of different cell types. A quantitative understanding of how a biological system works can be very powerful. For example, it could help us predict what would happen if we were to perturb a part. A mathematical model consists of one or more equations. An equation describes how different quantities are linked to each other. For example, how fast population size changes equals how fast new members are added through birth, minus how fast the existing members die. The growth and death rates are examples of model parameters. Back then, people had been modeling biological systems such as ecological communities, gene regulatory networks, and the cell division cycle. Some models matched data beautifully. However, the renowned mathematician and computer scientist John von Neumann once stated "with four parameters I can fit an elephant, and with five I can make him wiggle his trunk." In other words, given enough "free parameters" — parameters one could freely choose rather than being constrained by reality from experimental measurements, a model can be made to fit any data. Although a fitting model can explain data, it does not mean that the model is correct or can predict new data. To avoid the "free parameter" problem, I decided to start with a very simple system. In such a system, I should know exactly how parts interact with each other. I could then write down the equations, know which parameters need to be measured, and measure all parameters. After much deliberation, I decided to engineer a highly simplified cooperative yeast community consisting of two strains, each supplying the other with an essential metabolite. My colleagues and I thought of a lovely name for it: CoSMO — Cooperation that is Synthetic and Mutually Obligatory. Unlike real-life communities where scientists often have trouble counting the number of species, CoSMO has two and only two strains. Unlike real-life communities where species influence each other by releasing many uncharacterized chemicals, in CoSMO each strain releases only one metabolite which is required and consumed by the partner. Moreover in CoSMO, the two strains coexist due to their inter-dependence, and thus I do not need to worry about losing any one of them. Now that I know how the two strains interact with each other, it should in principle be easy to predict community properties, such as how fast the community grows — or community growth rate. Community growth rate primarily depends on two traits of each strain: the metabolite release rate and the amount of metabolite consumed per birth. Thus, modeling community growth rate boils down to measuring four parameters. This is by no means ambitious! Mission aborted I measured all four parameters. I measured the metabolite release and consumption traits of each strain in the absence of its partner. I got rid of the partner so that the released metabolites would accumulate in the test tube for me to measure, instead of being immediately consumed by the partner. However, since the partner was not present, the measurement environment (called the "batch culture" environment) differed from the community environment. For example, to measure metabolite consumption in batch cultures, I would add a high dose of metabolite at the beginning of an experiment. In contrast, in communities, the consumed metabolite is constantly supplied by the partner at a low level. Measuring strain traits in a community-like environment would require a special experimental setup. So, I had to hope that the batch culture environment could approximate the community environment. After measuring the four parameters, I predicted community growth rate. However, my prediction was way off from the experimental results. I was disappointed. In theory, a mathematical model is useful when it fails, because failure suggests that we are still missing important pieces. In reality, I was far from being thrilled by the failure, because too many pieces could be missing, even in a system as simple as CoSMO. For example, the batch culture environment might not approximate the community environment; cells could be evolving… The problem immediately becomes monstrously messy and un-elegant — a devil. Eventually, I aborted the mission. I was forced to ask whether I could explain some other community property — the minimal total cell density required for the community to start to grow. That calculation required measuring more parameters — such as cell growth rates at various metabolite concentrations. I did not have the experimental setup for such measurements, so I gave in to free parameters. I did what was, and is still, commonly done: looking for literature values. The literature values varied over an order of magnitude, so I naturally chose the value that could explain my data. I felt guilty, but comforted myself by noting that at least, the free parameter I chose was not outrageous, and that at least, the fraction of free parameters in my model was far lower than most other models. This reasoning did not exonerate me, but helped to bring a closure to my postdoc project (Shou et al., 2007). Haunted by the devil When I started my lab at the Hutch, I promptly locked up the devil in a closet. I felt caught: on the one hand, grant reviewers kept punishing me because "CoSMO is too simple", yet on the other hand, I could not even understand a very basic property of the community. My modeling failure was indeed humiliating. There was no way I could rephrase the question in an exciting fashion to attract any one, possibly even including myself. My group started working on other more sexy problems, such as how the two cooperating strains might fend off cheaters who consume but do not contribute metabolites (Momeni et al., 2013b; Waite and Shou, 2012). Despite group members' successes, the devil kept haunting me. Babak Momeni, then a postdoctoral fellow in my lab, examined spatial patterning in CoSMO when CoSMO grew on an agarose pad. When we compared patterns predicted by our model versus patterns observed in experiments, they looked similar in a qualitative sense. However, the timing looked very different. This is not surprising given that we do not understand how fast the community grows. Fortunately, dynamics was not the focus of that paper, so we erased all time stamps from our simulations (Momeni et al., 2013a). Devil breaking loose Eventually, the devil of my past failure would not allow me to ignore it any further. Chi-Chun Chen and Jose Pineda, two talented group members, were quantifying metabolite release rates of evolved cells. They wanted to see whether cells could evolve to be more "generous" by releasing more. However, Chi-Chun and Jose were getting highly variable results despite their superb experimental skills. It seemed that we got stuck when the question turned quantitative. We suspected that the variable measurement results could be due to cell traits being highly sensitive to the measurement environment. To enable measurements in a community-like environment, David Skelding — a physicist in the lab — started to build devices called "chemostats". In chemostats, nutrients were supplied at a small dose (in small drops) but frequently (every tens of seconds), mimicking partner strain's slow but constant metabolite release rate. It took David a good year or more to ensure that chemostats worked reliably and precisely (Skelding et al., 2018). Taming the devil When Sam Hart joined my lab as a research technician, he inherited the problems I, Chi-Chun, and Jose had left behind. Initially, Sam continued to quantify strain traits in batch cultures, because after all, chemostat measurements are much harder and are limited by the number of chambers. However, at some point, we realized that without getting our fundamentals on a solid footing, we would be chasing after our tails: If we do not understand the two ancestral strains (i.e. why ancestral strains' traits cannot explain ancestral community's growth rate), there is no point trying to understand evolved strains. By that time, Sam had already invested a year or two. But Sam was unflustered because he understood the importance of asking the right, albeit inconvenient, question. Sam re-measured ancestral strains' metabolite release and consumption traits in David's chemostats. By controlling how slowly metabolites were supplied, Sam could force cells to grow at various slow rates observed in CoSMO. However, chemostats introduced their own devil: because of metabolite limitation, cells from both strains quickly evolved away from their original states while adapting to metabolite limitation. Sam then figured out ways to deal with this new problem. Eventually, Sam discovered that indeed, measurements of metabolite release and consumption traits could differ significantly in chemostats versus in batch cultures. Hanbing Mi, an undergraduate visiting student from China, figured out how to properly measure community growth rate when cells could evolve quickly. Once we took all these into consideration, we solved the puzzle (Hart et al., 2019). But only partially: we still do not understand CoSMO's initial phase of slower growth. Using the same quantification methodology that we have found to be trustworthy, Sam figured out what it means to be "generous" (Hart & Pineda et al., 2019), and which mutants evolved to be more generous (manuscript in preparation). Sam is now a graduate student at the University of Washington. Summary It takes a lot to do careful science. For science to advance, it must stand on a solid foundation. By demonstrating how to properly model a very simple living system, we have helped setting the standard for future modeling of more complex systems such as probiotic communities or infectious diseases. Acknowledgements I am very grateful to my lab members, particularly Sam Hart, Hanbing Mi, Jose Pineda, Chi-Chun Chen, and David Skelding, for doing high-quality work. Hart & Pineda, Chen, Chichun, Green, Robin, Shou W. 2019. Disentangling strictly self-serving mutations from win-win mutations in a mutualistic microbial community. eLife Accepted. Hart SFM, Mi H, Green R, Xie L, Pineda JMB, Momeni B, Shou W. 2019. Uncovering and resolving challenges of quantitative modeling in a simplified community of interacting cells. PLOS Biol 17:e3000135. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3000135 Momeni B, Brileya KA, Fields MW, Shou W. 2013a. Strong inter-population cooperation leads to partner intermixing in microbial communities. eLife 2:e00230. doi:10.7554/eLife.00230 Momeni B, Waite AJ, Shou W. 2013b. Spatial self-organization favors heterotypic cooperation over cheating. eLife 2:e00960. doi:10.7554/eLife.00960 Shou W, Ram S, Vilar JM. 2007. Synthetic cooperation in engineered yeast populations. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104:1877–1882. doi:10.1073/pnas.0610575104 Skelding D, Hart SF, Vidyasagar T, Pozhitkov AE, Shou W. 2018. Developing a low-cost milliliter-scale chemostat array for precise control of cellular growth. Quant Biol 6:129–141. Waite AJ, Shou W. 2012. Adaptation to a new environment allows cooperators to purge cheaters stochastically. Proc Natl Acad Sci 109:19079–19086. doi:10.1073/pnas.1210190109
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Alex's Asteroid Astrology |. Asteroid astrology - current headlines, Trump astrology, celebrity and event charts, mythic asteroids, personal named asteroids (PNAs) and more.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Smakminnen | Sveriges matcommunity för gamla recept. Sveriges samlingsplats för gamla recept. Här hittar du allt från medeltida recept fram till 80-talets recept. Både kuriosa om mat förr, recept att häpnas över och recept man minns.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Shengping Zhang. I am a Professor in the school of Computer Science and Technology, Harbin Institute of Technology, China. My research interests include Deep learning and its applications in computer vision. In particular, I am currently focusing on object classification, visual tracking and action recognition, etc. My research works were published in top-tier journals such as PNAS, JMLR, IEEE T-PAMI,…
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
易汉博基因科技 | 生物信息. EHBIO gene technology is founded by Doctors graduated from Chinese Academy of Sciences and WuHan University. Former government officer and Chief scientist of Chinese Academy of Sceinces in chanrge of company operation. We focus on applying the latest and most accurate bioinformatics technology to deal with the big data in basic research and medical research. Our talented team members include EHBIO gene technology (Beijing) co., LTD., is founded by bases on scientific research service, to escort health mission, with deep research accumulation and exquisite bioinformatics analysis technology, is committed to promoting the development of scientific research and medical treatment. 易汉博基因科技,以服务科研为出发点,以护航健康为使命,利用深厚的科研积累与精湛的生物信息学分析技术,致力推动科研与医疗事业的发展。 公司由中国科学院及武汉大学等高校的优秀博士、硕士毕业生创建,由中央国家机关工委办公室前主任和中科院首席科学家统筹管理,致力于利用最前沿与最精确的生物信息分析技术,帮助解析基础研究和临床应用相关的高通量数据的专业数据。 易汉博技术团队在生物信息领域具有很高的造诣,团队成员以科学问题为导向,依托精湛的生物信息分析技术和丰富的实验生物学设计经验,在攻读学位或博士后进修期间获得了多个创新性研究成果,并发表于Cell, Cell Stem Cell, PNAS, JBC, NAR, New Phytologist, Bioinformatics等杂志。 公司现有服务的客户来自中国科学院、中国中医科学院、北医三院、南开大学、中国农业大学等科研或医疗机构。
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
易汉博基因科技 | 生物信息. EHBIO gene technology is founded by Doctors graduated from Chinese Academy of Sciences and WuHan University. Former government officer and Chief scientist of Chinese Academy of Sceinces in chanrge of company operation. We focus on applying the latest and most accurate bioinformatics technology to deal with the big data in basic research and medical research. Our talented team members include EHBIO gene technology (Beijing) co., LTD., is founded by bases on scientific research service, to escort health mission, with deep research accumulation and exquisite bioinformatics analysis technology, is committed to promoting the development of scientific research and medical treatment. 易汉博基因科技,以服务科研为出发点,以护航健康为使命,利用深厚的科研积累与精湛的生物信息学分析技术,致力推动科研与医疗事业的发展。 公司由中国科学院及武汉大学等高校的优秀博士、硕士毕业生创建,由中央国家机关工委办公室前主任和中科院首席科学家统筹管理,致力于利用最前沿与最精确的生物信息分析技术,帮助解析基础研究和临床应用相关的高通量数据的专业数据。 易汉博技术团队在生物信息领域具有很高的造诣,团队成员以科学问题为导向,依托精湛的生物信息分析技术和丰富的实验生物学设计经验,在攻读学位或博士后进修期间获得了多个创新性研究成果,并发表于Cell, Cell Stem Cell, PNAS, JBC, NAR, New Phytologist, Bioinformatics等杂志。 公司现有服务的客户来自中国科学院、中国中医科学院、北医三院、南开大学、中国农业大学等科研或医疗机构。
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Alex's Asteroid Astrology |. Asteroid astrology - current headlines, Trump astrology, celebrity and event charts, mythic asteroids, personal named asteroids (PNAs) and more.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Dr Mariolino (Lino) Carta Research Lab. I graduated in Chemistry in Italy in 2004 with a master project based on the synthesis of novel Peptide Nucleic Acids monomers (PNAs). I then moved to Cardiff University to obtain a PhD in Organic Material Chemistry in 2009 with a thesis project based on the synthesis and characterisation of novel monomers for the synthesis of…
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
National Academy of Sciences
Alexa Rank
405,477
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. eJournalPress is mission critical software providing online submission, review and tracking of manuscripts via the Internet. It was designed from the ground up to provide rock solid security, reliability and ease of use.
Alexa Rank
409,587
marxlabui | Marx Laboratory, University of Idaho. Marx Laboratory, University of Idaho
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Nathalie Katsonis. Nathalie Katsonis, based at Universiteit Twente, specializes in the development of bio-inspired, smart materials.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Nathalie Katsonis. Nathalie Katsonis, based at Universiteit Twente, specializes in the development of bio-inspired, smart materials.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Marc Santolini – Network science for medicine and collaborative projects. Network science for medicine and collaborative projects
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Boundary Vision | Observations of the spaces in between science, society, education and policy.. Observations of the spaces in between science, society, education and policy.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
chris-doughty
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Today's Science ಇಂದಿನ ವಿಜ್ಞಾನ | ಕನ್ನಡದ ವಿಜ್ಞಾನ ಸುದ್ದಿ ಪತ್ರ. ಎಲ್ಲ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರಿಗೂ ಆತ್ಮೀಯ ಸ್ವಾಗತ. ನಿತ್ಯ ಬದುಕಿಗೆ ತಳುಕಿಕೊಂಡ ಸ್ವಾರಸ್ಯಕರ ಸಂಶೋಧನೆಗಳು ಇಲ್ಲಿವೆ.. ಕನ್ನಡದ ವಿಜ್ಞಾನ ಸುದ್ದಿ ಪತ್ರ. ಎಲ್ಲ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರಿಗೂ ಆತ್ಮೀಯ ಸ್ವಾಗತ. ನಿತ್ಯ ಬದುಕಿಗೆ ತಳುಕಿಕೊಂಡ ಸ್ವಾರಸ್ಯಕರ ಸಂಶೋಧನೆಗಳು ಇಲ್ಲಿವೆ.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
ALIGNED
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Alok Gupta | Data Scientist in Predictive Modeling and Machine Learning. Avid fan of Buses.. Data Scientist in Predictive Modeling and Machine Learning. Avid fan of Buses.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. eJournalPress is mission critical software providing online submission, review and tracking of manuscripts via the Internet. It was designed from the ground up to provide rock solid security, reliability and ease of use.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Today's Science ಇಂದಿನ ವಿಜ್ಞಾನ | ಕನ್ನಡದ ವಿಜ್ಞಾನ ಸುದ್ದಿ ಪತ್ರ. ಎಲ್ಲ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರಿಗೂ ಆತ್ಮೀಯ ಸ್ವಾಗತ. ನಿತ್ಯ ಬದುಕಿಗೆ ತಳುಕಿಕೊಂಡ ಸ್ವಾರಸ್ಯಕರ ಸಂಶೋಧನೆಗಳು ಇಲ್ಲಿವೆ.. ಕನ್ನಡದ ವಿಜ್ಞಾನ ಸುದ್ದಿ ಪತ್ರ. ಎಲ್ಲ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರಿಗೂ ಆತ್ಮೀಯ ಸ್ವಾಗತ. ನಿತ್ಯ ಬದುಕಿಗೆ ತಳುಕಿಕೊಂಡ ಸ್ವಾರಸ್ಯಕರ ಸಂಶೋಧನೆಗಳು ಇಲ್ಲಿವೆ.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
NANOLEI - Law and Nano. Nanotecnologia e Leis; Nanotechnology and Law; Nanotechnologien und Gesetze; Nanotecnologías y Leyes;нанотехнологии и законы;
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Wildly overgrown ... tidbits from archaeology
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
National Academy of Sciences
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Science Dryad | Data science blog. Data science blog
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Millimetre Wave, Sub-millimeter Wave / THz Technology Custom Design & Development. Supply millimeter wave, sub-millimeter wave / THz subsystem, module, and component
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
JETIR- Journal of Emerging Technologies and Innovative Research. Journal of Emerging Technologies and Innovative Research is not limited to a specific field of engineering but is instead devoted to a wide range of subfields in the engineering sciences.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
JETIR- Journal of Emerging Technologies and Innovative Research. Journal of Emerging Technologies and Innovative Research is not limited to a specific field of engineering but is instead devoted to a wide range of subfields in the engineering sciences.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Energy By Design | Sustainability-focused MEP/FP Engineering & Energy Efficiency Consulting | 2RW. Innovative, efficient MEP/FP system design and energy consulting services. We develop innovative solutions that help building owners create high-performing buildings, reduce building TCO, improve occupant comfort and safety, and tread lightly on the planet.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Energy By Design | Sustainability-focused MEP/FP Engineering & Energy Efficiency Consulting | 2RW. Innovative, efficient MEP/FP system design and energy consulting services. We develop innovative solutions that help building owners create high-performing buildings, reduce building TCO, improve occupant comfort and safety, and tread lightly on the planet.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Biodiversity and Evolutionary Biology Department. Welcome to the web page of the Department of Biodiversity and Evolutionary Biology of the National Museum of Natural Sciences in Madrid, Spain.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Biodiversity and Evolutionary Biology Department. Welcome to the web page of the Department of Biodiversity and Evolutionary Biology of the National Museum of Natural Sciences in Madrid, Spain.
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Free PDF Search - Download all research articles for free
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Gross Funk GmbH | DIE SICHERE FUNKFERNSTEUERUNG FÜR IHRE MASCHINE
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Free PDF Search - Download all research articles for free
Alexa Rank
1,000,001
Alexa Rank
1,000,001